Experts Highlight Unusual Details in Footage From Nancy Guthrie Case
New analysis is shedding light on surveillance footage connected to the disappearance of Nancy Guthrie, the 84-year-old mother of TODAY co-anchor Savannah Guthrie. As the search enters its twelfth day, experts are examining subtle details in the video that could prove significant.
Nancy vanished from her Tucson, Arizona home and was reported missing on February 1. Authorities launched a large-scale investigation after blood confirmed to belong to her was discovered at the property. On February 10, the FBI released images and video captured by a Nest security camera, showing a masked individual approaching the residence at night.

Credit / FBI & Getty Images
In one frame, the person appears to be carrying what looks like a firearm positioned toward the front of their body. Former FBI agent Mark Harrigan described the manner of carrying the weapon as highly unusual. Speaking to media outlets, he noted that individuals attempting to avoid detection typically conceal weapons rather than display them openly. The positioning, he suggested, could indicate a specific intent or level of confidence.
Adding another layer of analysis, body language expert Susan Constantine focused on the suspect’s backpack. According to her assessment, the bag appeared “already full” before the individual approached the home. She pointed out that in typical burglary scenarios, suspects often arrive with minimal gear and may operate in teams with defined roles. A single person approaching through the main entrance with a filled backpack, she suggested, does not align with common burglary patterns.
Continue reading on the next page…